choosing to die
- Thread starter brettjameshill
- Start date
Christ, that was hard to watch. For all kinds of reasons.
I wouldn't do it myself - but then I'm not terminally ill. At the moment. Things may (almost certainly will, given my genetics) change as I get older and I have seen enough people die slowly and in pain not to want to do it myself, so.....
We put down our pets when they are old and ill - why not ourselves?
Thanks, Terry for yet another well-argued piece in favour of humanity.
And thanks to the late Peter Smedley ("a truly brave man", as Terry said) for allowing his last moments to be filmed for the programme.
I wouldn't do it myself - but then I'm not terminally ill. At the moment. Things may (almost certainly will, given my genetics) change as I get older and I have seen enough people die slowly and in pain not to want to do it myself, so.....
We put down our pets when they are old and ill - why not ourselves?
Thanks, Terry for yet another well-argued piece in favour of humanity.
And thanks to the late Peter Smedley ("a truly brave man", as Terry said) for allowing his last moments to be filmed for the programme.
i have to agree in right time right place, as much as we carnt see into the future but people who have terminal illness' almost have a view on what will happen, so choosing to take your life in this way i fully understand and sympathise with thier families but consider the person who is ill and carnt make the decision when its to late. Alan and Peter are now at peace and no more pain or suffering...Terry you have shook the world again and got them talking about such a taboo subject well done and carry on doing what you do best and when you come to make your decision no one will judge you as you are elite and cleverer than they think. no one can tell anyone who is right until your in thier shoes...... xxxxx
Thank you for making this programme. Eloquent, thought (and I hope debate) provoking and moving.
As having been diagnosed with a 'life limiting illness' this debate goes straight to the heart. Although I (hopefully) have a long, long time before I may face the desire to make this choice, for those that have to face it now, I wish you all the best and hope you are given the option to choose if you want it.
Love to all on this site, whatever your views and I hope you all live long and full lives.
Peter and Andrew were wonderfully brave people, as are their families and my heart goes out to them and thank you for letting us share their lives and deaths.
Nimrod or The Great Gig in the Sky? Not sure now!
As having been diagnosed with a 'life limiting illness' this debate goes straight to the heart. Although I (hopefully) have a long, long time before I may face the desire to make this choice, for those that have to face it now, I wish you all the best and hope you are given the option to choose if you want it.
Love to all on this site, whatever your views and I hope you all live long and full lives.
Peter and Andrew were wonderfully brave people, as are their families and my heart goes out to them and thank you for letting us share their lives and deaths.
Nimrod or The Great Gig in the Sky? Not sure now!
BBC film
One of the best made documentaries that I have ever watched. The bravery of Peter ( and Andrew) was stunning. We treat our pets better than we do ourselves. Sir Terry showed courage in filming and keeping a balanced view point. Thank you and I hope this is the start for change that will give people in very painful situation the respect they deserve.
One of the best made documentaries that I have ever watched. The bravery of Peter ( and Andrew) was stunning. We treat our pets better than we do ourselves. Sir Terry showed courage in filming and keeping a balanced view point. Thank you and I hope this is the start for change that will give people in very painful situation the respect they deserve.
! Welcome to you all. I watched it and for those who don't know I am 14. I didn't cry (the result of trying very hard not to admittedly). I fully support people's right to choose too. Very good documentary.
A very moving documentary, well presented, thankfully not dumbed down. My respect and admiration for Terry is unfaltering but I would really like to add Rob his assistant in both that admiration and respect now.
Got a bit annoyed with Disabled Rights Person on the Newsnight programme - she really shouldn't have kept reiteration that disabled people felt the same as she - I am and I don't !
Got a bit annoyed with Disabled Rights Person on the Newsnight programme - she really shouldn't have kept reiteration that disabled people felt the same as she - I am and I don't !
I've just read the news of Mr Pratchett choosing an assisted death and I'm crying like hell right now. I just wanted to tell him how much he influenced my way of seeing and feeling the world, how he opened my horizons and made this world an easier place to live by putting more magic into it. I feel Mr Pratchett so close, as if he were my father. So I do hope that there will be no need for him to take such a decision in the near future. I pray that he may keep on living and writing because our small personal worlds would be greyer and emptier without him.
I just had to join this site today to show my support for Terry Pratchett in his making of the documentary, 'Choosing to Die'. I have not been so moved by a documentary for a long time, and yes I cried throughout, but not in pity or disgust, but in admiration of the bravery of all involved. My heart went out to Andrew and Peter and their families. Peter's last moments were truly heartbreaking yet I can totally empathise with the decisions taken and would fully support the same actions if I had to.
I felt so sad that these people had been denied the dignity of being able to do this in their own homes, in familiar and comforting surroundings.
Thank you Terry.
I felt so sad that these people had been denied the dignity of being able to do this in their own homes, in familiar and comforting surroundings.
Thank you Terry.
