New Pratchett for 2012

Welcome to the Sir Terry Pratchett Forums
Register here for the Sir Terry Pratchett forum and message boards.
Sign up

pip

Sergeant-at-Arms
Sep 3, 2010
8,765
2,850
KILDARE
#41
meerkat said:
Tonyblack said:
meerkat said:
Roll on June!
Poor June. Won't she object? :laugh:
Yep, left myself walk right into that one, didn't I? :laugh:

Raisindot, I was piqued by what was in the books Young Sam was reading. I;d be interested to see what this has in it (yes, I know, it's poo!) but it seemed to hint at how sanitation works and other matters relating to poo. Could be instructive!

J K Rowling did it with Tales of Beedle the Bard, so I don't see why Sir T can't do likewise with Felicity Beedle books! ;)
JK Rowling did give every penny fromk that to charity though . Will terry do the same
 

Batty

Sergeant
Feb 17, 2009
4,154
2,600
East Anglia
#42
meerkat said:
What is it about an elephant and it's poo? :rolleyes:
Some years ago, we had a circus in Town, and all the elephant dung was piled up and residents invited to help themselves.
No doubt a few did. Until after a hot spell, the pile burst into flames! :laugh:
 

raisindot

Sergeant-at-Arms
Oct 1, 2009
5,317
2,450
Boston, MA USA
#43
pip said:
Like Wheres my Cow i thought the whole Pooh book thing was a commentary on childrens book. In the Uk theres a big trend in childrens books about poo (not the bear) and Terry does do social commentary .
I have nothing against poo books, other than not being a fan of the end product. (ba-da boom).

I, too, thought Pterry was mentioning the poo book in Snuff simply as a commentary on the idea that there are children's books on just about every topic. If Pterry had decided to write a standalone kids book about poo, I wouldn't have minded either--wouldn't have bought it, but wouldn't have cared.

It's the fact that he takes a subject that isn't particularly central to the story--poo and books about poo--and uses it to flog the sales of the separate book he's writing about that gets my goat. I'd feel a lot less bothered by it if he had written a separate kids book about goblins, since they are at least a central theme in Snuff. And maybe I'd be less bothered by it if I felt that Snuff wasn't one of Pterry's worst books in ages. But that's just me. Your kilometerage, of course, may vary.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
#44
And hey, as far as I got in snuff by now, there aren't even any interesting facts about dung. Like, did you know that up till today horsedung is used when making churchbells?

And instead of that 'tie-in' they should perhaps update the worldmap...
 

pip

Sergeant-at-Arms
Sep 3, 2010
8,765
2,850
KILDARE
#45
raisindot said:
pip said:
Like Wheres my Cow i thought the whole Pooh book thing was a commentary on childrens book. In the Uk theres a big trend in childrens books about poo (not the bear) and Terry does do social commentary .
I have nothing against poo books, other than not being a fan of the end product. (ba-da boom).

I, too, thought Pterry was mentioning the poo book in Snuff simply as a commentary on the idea that there are children's books on just about every topic. If Pterry had decided to write a standalone kids book about poo, I wouldn't have minded either--wouldn't have bought it, but wouldn't have cared.

It's the fact that he takes a subject that isn't particularly central to the story--poo and books about poo--and uses it to flog the sales of the separate book he's writing about that gets my goat. I'd feel a lot less bothered by it if he had written a separate kids book about goblins, since they are at least a central theme in Snuff. And maybe I'd be less bothered by it if I felt that Snuff wasn't one of Pterry's worst books in ages. But that's just me. Your kilometerage, of course, may vary.
maybe it would be easier to accept if the spinoff was a charity thing like ms Rowlings side works i suppose.
i would love to see an up to date full discworld map more than this and wheres my cow style spinoffa though so subconciously i probably agree with you
 
Jan 13, 2012
2,337
2,600
South florida, US
www.youtube.com
#46
pip said:
Like Wheres my Cow i thought the whole Pooh book thing was a commentary on childrens book. In the Uk theres a big trend in childrens books about poo (not the bear) and Terry does do social commentary . Maybe its bypassed the states but you'd be amazed at the amount of mainstream books available as highlighted below.




you missed the most famous one of all
 

Attachments

A

Anonymous

Guest
#48
With my day job I can see this being a very popular book, I will be getting two then claiming them back as business expense :)
 

The Mad Collector

Sergeant-at-Arms
Sep 1, 2010
9,918
2,850
62
Ironbridge UK
www.bearsonthesquare.com
#55
raisindot said:
Another reason for me to dislike Snuff. I kept wondering why there was so much discussion of poo in general and this kind of book in general, and here we have it--like "Where's My Cow" and the Thud board game in Thud!, they're included as product placements. While these placements were forgiveable in Thud because that book is a masterpiece and these products are integral to the plot of the story, "The World of Poo" does nothing to advance the story in Snuff.

The Thud game predates the book by several years. In fact this example is the other way round as the book was inspired by the already existing game.

However "The World of Poo" sound like a crap book. :rolleyes:
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
#57
The german title of that mole book is simply -of the little mole that wanted to know who shat on his head-
Why is Germany so straight forward with it?
 

Penfold

Sergeant-at-Arms
Dec 29, 2009
9,125
3,050
Worthing
www.lenbrookphotography.com
#59
On this subject, while I was at the Wetlands Trust the other day, a family with a very young child (about 3-4 years old) were sitting in the hide overlooking the lake. The kid had no interest whatsoever in watching the birds but was very keen to point out all the poos left behind by the ducks and geese. :laugh: Having read "Snuff", I had to leave because having to stifle my laughter so much was starting to hurt.
 

User Menu

Newsletter