Snuff audiobook

Welcome to the Sir Terry Pratchett Forums
Register here for the Sir Terry Pratchett forum and message boards.
Sign up

Wyrdskein

Lance-Constable
Sep 9, 2014
13
1,750
50
Kent (UK)
#1
Just about to start listening to Snuff, read by Stephen Briggs - this is after being disappointed by Raising Steam, although I understand it may have been the difficult prose that made it hard to listen to. Having listened back to the end of Raising Steam, Briggs is fine when he's flowing, so maybe it's the language that is the problem.

Has anyone else heard Snuff?

I will let you know how I get on.
 

raisindot

Sergeant-at-Arms
Oct 1, 2009
5,317
2,450
Boston, MA USA
#2
Yes, I have both the book and audiobook versions of Snuff. Briggs has trouble with lots of it, probably for the same reasons you thought his Raising Steam reading wasn't the best. Pterry's "new style" for DW books is plagued by endlessly long and tortured paragraphs of exposition, and what used to be sharp and succint dialogue has been replaced by long-winded speechifying where everything a character is thinking or doing is spelled out, whereas in the past, Pterry let the reader infer the actions more from what was not "said" in the writing. Briggs' reading of Willikens is particularly strained, because Willikens shifts back and forth from this "upper class" dialogue to "street slang," sometimes in mid-sentence, and the "voice" that Briggs uses for him--which worked spectacularly in Thud!--doesn't work well at all here. Briggs often has so many words to read in one sentence that he loses the narrative grip. I don't think this is his fault at all--he is simply working with subpar material. Briggs is at this best when he's reading short sentences and scenes of dialogue. The latest DW books are not his forte. To his defense, I don't think Nigel Planer would have done a better job, either.
 
Nov 15, 2011
3,310
2,650
Aust.
#4
While I haven't listened to Stephen Briggs read a DW novel, I don't like the way Robinson or Planer read them at all. It's because of the character voices. I'd like them to just read the novel without pulling stupid sounding (imo) voices e.g. the witches. Why don't they use different voice actors if that's the effect they are going for? I think it makes the DW & it's amazing characters sound ridiculous.

Keeping slightly on topic, I'll try Stephen Briggs before I keep away from DW audio books altogether but I won't bother with any more read by Planer or Robinson.
 

raisindot

Sergeant-at-Arms
Oct 1, 2009
5,317
2,450
Boston, MA USA
#6
Sister Jennifer said:
While I haven't listened to Stephen Briggs read a DW novel, I don't like the way Robinson or Planer read them at all. It's because of the character voices. I'd like them to just read the novel without pulling stupid sounding (imo) voices e.g. the witches. Why don't they use different voice actors if that's the effect they are going for? I think it makes the DW & it's amazing characters sound ridiculous.

Keeping slightly on topic, I'll try Stephen Briggs before I keep away from DW audio books altogether but I won't bother with any more read by Planer or Robinson.
That's interesting. I like it when Planer and Briggs use different voices for characters. It makes them come alive. For me, Planer's witch voices are spot-on, to the point that when I hear Briggs reading Nanny and Granny they just sound "wrong." The best thing about these two is that they don't try to sound like "women" when they're reading women's parts--they don't use falsettos or try to feminize them. It's hard to figure out what it works, but, for the most part, it does. Celie Imrie, on the other hand, is an awful reader. I can't even listen to Wyrd Sisters anymore.
 

Wyrdskein

Lance-Constable
Sep 9, 2014
13
1,750
50
Kent (UK)
#8
Stephen Briggs' character voices are pretty good. None of them seem out of place.

Like Raising Steam, the prose seems rather long-winded at times, but over all I enjoyed it quite a lot.
 

raisindot

Sergeant-at-Arms
Oct 1, 2009
5,317
2,450
Boston, MA USA
#9
That's good to hear. I just got the Raising Steam audiobook and will start listening to as soon as the weather gets warm enough for me to run outside again (I can't run unless I have an audiobook or music to listen to--the activity is much too boring without audio stimulation).
 
Jan 13, 2012
2,337
2,600
South florida, US
www.youtube.com
#10
Both Briggs and Planer have their strengths. Planer's witches (especially Nanny Ogg), death, and detritus, are much preferred. while Briggs' has Vimes, Angua, vetinari, and ridcully. and there are other little ones here and there that one seems to do better then the other. the rest i can take either one.

And yeah, adding the voices, one makes the characters stand out from one another. and two, adds depth to them. allows for them to have inflections, emotions.
 

User Menu

Newsletter